THOMSON’S LAMP – CAN YOU SOLVE IT?

Before we begin, you probably can’t solve it.

In 1954 James Thomson, a british philosopher, came up with a captivating puzzle. It has since troubled the minds of many scientists (and everyone willing to find the solution), but the answer remains unclear.

The puzzle goes like this:

Imagine a lamp with a switch – it can be either on or off (obviously). You have two minutes to turn the light on and off consecutively. The first time you turn on the light – you leave it on for a full minute, and then you turn it off. You leave it off for 30 seconds (1/2 of a minute), and then you turn it back on again. After 15 seconds (1/4 of a minute), you turn it off and then leave it like that for 7.5 seconds (1/8 of a minute), and so on.
The questions is:  After two minutes, will the lamp be on or off?

1914949_10205562611284345_8712859629765602945_n12360287_10205562612284370_6401968626359594010_n

The solution:

The truth is, the solution is too complicated for our non-Einstein minds, but if you are desperately eager to find it out, check it here:

http://somethingworthreading.org/first-known-solution-to-thomsons-lamp/
(note: even this solution is not proved to be correct, and there are still no official answers to this paradox)

James Thomson called this puzzle a supertask. A supertask is:  „countably infinite sequence of operations that occur sequentially within a finite interval of time.“ In other words – it’s an EXTREMELY complicated task that actually requires a mind more advanced than the one humans have. For example, Achilles and the tortoise was also a supertask.

Napisala: Mateja Napravnik

Odgovori